Werewolf: Round 1 Begins!

LSP seems to make a last minute dash to dissuade us from lynching her.

She changed her vote from partjoker.
She was never called suspicious by partjoker.
She knows a lot of useful information.


Either way, it's too risky. Even with the small chance you are a villager, it would still narrow it down to the remaining 3 "neutral" people.

I hesitantly say LSP.

Oh come on, just because I'm not organized or sure of you doesn't mean I'm not on your side. I mean, we're all suspicious of eachother a little bit. Except the masons I guess. No one else really has proof. Atleast not that I know of. No one's told me much :/

I vote LSP

I half-think LSP's a villager now, but I don't care. Sticking with my original vote for LSP.

Why am I so suspicious? Any of us could have fallen into partjoker's trap! It was just me
But, like, what about all those inactive people? Seems to me like they are in the perfect position to sit back and watch us take eachother out while they kill us at night... I KNOW I said that about Kuph before, but that was before I knew he was a mason, and also he's active now. What about TV Face and that other person whose name I actually forgot because it's been so long... Mr Carter's not in the country but that doesn't mean he can't be sending in assassination votes at night.

Alright, villagers. I say we humor this request and take one of the inactive members down today, MrCarter.

If MrCarter is a villager, however, our choices will be narrowed down to LSP, rayoflight, and TV Face. Since there's 2 wolves remaining, and 3 "unidentified/neutral" players, everyone has a 2:3 chance of being a wolf.

Hahah, wouldn't it be funny if Mr. Carter really doesn't have access to a computer and he comes back from Europe and he's dead?

Well I guess it would be pretty sad actually.

We'll see, Mr. Carter. We'll see.

Even though I've suspected LSP for a while, I agree with Jman on eliminating the inactive MrCarter. Since we have absolutely no information on MrCarter to develop any opinions, it's a complete guess at his role, and if we don't get it out of the way, it can only mess with us later.
As for assasinations, I believe we're safe during the night. My hypothesis is that LSP is the Devil, and with MrCarter inactive as the other wolf, no assasination votes can be made. If anyone should be killed during the night, then it will be revealing. In our hypothetical standing, we can sleep sound through each night, and lynch a suspected werewolf each day untill we weed the last ones out.
Today I vote MrCarter

Kuph, you do know the Devil is allowed to vote if they're the only Wolf left, right?

Time to die Mr. Carter.

You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

markmarkadam wrote:You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

Wow that's a really good point... With that in mind, I'd feel safer with TV Face gone than with Mr Carter gone. Mr Carter we could give the benefit of the doubt but TV Face has no excuse.

LSP wrote:

markmarkadam wrote:You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

Wow that's a really good point... With that in mind, I'd feel safer with TV Face gone than with Mr Carter gone. Mr Carter we could give the benefit of the doubt but TV Face has no excuse.

All that is a good point, but forget not that a lack of death doesn't automatically mean somebody didn't send in their votes, but more likely that whoever was targeted was also baned.
True Mr. Carter would make a strange selection for wolf, but that also would be a clever move too. Making the ghost player the dangerous one, sending in his assassination votes at night. There have been a bunch of guest viewers browsing the forums recently, maybe Mr. Carter is browsing anonymously and then secretly assassinating, laughing as people automatically remove him from suspicion solely because he's far away.
The dead have no vote here, so my opinion really doesn't matter all that much.
Also, if TV Face were a good wolf, he would be active in the day cycles too, trying to get some innocents lynched. Just because he only posts at night isn't really a sound indication either.
All i'm trying to say is that the above reasons aren't really reasons much to do anything. But then again i suppose a half-reason is better than random lynching from no reason.

I saw a guest on today from Germany. Could that be MrCarter as a guest watching over us ever so secretly?

Elmo wrote:

LSP wrote:

markmarkadam wrote:You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

Wow that's a really good point... With that in mind, I'd feel safer with TV Face gone than with Mr Carter gone. Mr Carter we could give the benefit of the doubt but TV Face has no excuse.

All that is a good point, but forget not that a lack of death doesn't automatically mean somebody didn't send in their votes, but more likely that whoever was targeted was also baned.
True Mr. Carter would make a strange selection for wolf, but that also would be a clever move too. Making the ghost player the dangerous one, sending in his assassination votes at night. There have been a bunch of guest viewers browsing the forums recently, maybe Mr. Carter is browsing anonymously and then secretly assassinating, laughing as people automatically remove him from suspicion solely because he's far away.
The dead have no vote here, so my opinion really doesn't matter all that much.
Also, if TV Face were a good wolf, he would be active in the day cycles too, trying to get some innocents lynched. Just because he only posts at night isn't really a sound indication either.
All i'm trying to say is that the above reasons aren't really reasons much to do anything. But then again i suppose a half-reason is better than random lynching from no reason.

My point exactly. If TVFACE were a good wolf he'd be active in day aswell as night. nobody died last night, and if he were a wolf it'd be his responsibility to assasinate. if he is a wolf, he's not a good one, but a wolf nonetheless.

MrCarter will still be a nuisance and he must die. He hasn't posted a single time so we will be paranoid until we know his role. The only way to find that out is to kill him.

Elmo wrote:

LSP wrote:

markmarkadam wrote:You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

Wow that's a really good point... With that in mind, I'd feel safer with TV Face gone than with Mr Carter gone. Mr Carter we could give the benefit of the doubt but TV Face has no excuse.

All that is a good point, but forget not that a lack of death doesn't automatically mean somebody didn't send in their votes, but more likely that whoever was targeted was also baned.
True Mr. Carter would make a strange selection for wolf, but that also would be a clever move too. Making the ghost player the dangerous one, sending in his assassination votes at night. There have been a bunch of guest viewers browsing the forums recently, maybe Mr. Carter is browsing anonymously and then secretly assassinating, laughing as people automatically remove him from suspicion solely because he's far away.
The dead have no vote here, so my opinion really doesn't matter all that much.
Also, if TV Face were a good wolf, he would be active in the day cycles too, trying to get some innocents lynched. Just because he only posts at night isn't really a sound indication either.
All i'm trying to say is that the above reasons aren't really reasons much to do anything. But then again i suppose a half-reason is better than random lynching from no reason.

So maybe he's not a good wolf. But Mr Carter hasn't posted at all and wouldn't that make him a bad wolf too if he is one? What Im thinking is that if both he and Mr Carter are basically inactive, Mr Carter has more of an excuse than he does. And either way I think Kuph was right in saying it would benefit us to get an inactive player out of the way, because we have no evidence for or against them really, and even if whoever we lynch today turns out to be a villager, well that's sad, but it's worth it if they're a wolf, and even if theyre a villager there are only two wolves left and it would be easier to assess who's good and who's bad. SO if it's between TV Face and Mr Carter, I think TV Face is a tad bit more suspicious.

Alright. I'll consider what you're saying and change my vote yet again to TV Face for now.

LSP wrote:

Elmo wrote:

LSP wrote:

markmarkadam wrote:You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

Wow that's a really good point... With that in mind, I'd feel safer with TV Face gone than with Mr Carter gone. Mr Carter we could give the benefit of the doubt but TV Face has no excuse.

All that is a good point, but forget not that a lack of death doesn't automatically mean somebody didn't send in their votes, but more likely that whoever was targeted was also baned.
True Mr. Carter would make a strange selection for wolf, but that also would be a clever move too. Making the ghost player the dangerous one, sending in his assassination votes at night. There have been a bunch of guest viewers browsing the forums recently, maybe Mr. Carter is browsing anonymously and then secretly assassinating, laughing as people automatically remove him from suspicion solely because he's far away.
The dead have no vote here, so my opinion really doesn't matter all that much.
Also, if TV Face were a good wolf, he would be active in the day cycles too, trying to get some innocents lynched. Just because he only posts at night isn't really a sound indication either.
All i'm trying to say is that the above reasons aren't really reasons much to do anything. But then again i suppose a half-reason is better than random lynching from no reason.

So maybe he's not a good wolf. But Mr Carter hasn't posted at all and wouldn't that make him a bad wolf too if he is one? What Im thinking is that if both he and Mr Carter are basically inactive, Mr Carter has more of an excuse than he does. And either way I think Kuph was right in saying it would benefit us to get an inactive player out of the way, because we have no evidence for or against them really, and even if whoever we lynch today turns out to be a villager, well that's sad, but it's worth it if they're a wolf, and even if theyre a villager there are only two wolves left and it would be easier to assess who's good and who's bad. SO if it's between TV Face and Mr Carter, I think TV Face is a tad bit more suspicious.

also mccarter for all we know has been 100% inactive while TVFACE actually posted once. The one night anybody was killed, and when elmo was killed even though he was baned. in other words he had 3 votes protecting him, and 4 killing him. Yet the night TVFACE doesn't post, nobody votes to assasinate, and nobody dies. Also while i understand your concern with mccarter not playing at all, let me ask you this: which one's demise benefits the game more? I think my evidence should speak for itself.

No need to argue to convince me, i'm already dead...

Kuph, you do know the Devil is allowed to vote if they're the only Wolf left, right?

Ah, thank you, I overlooked that. That's important to keep in mind.

You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

Good point, that shatters my prediction of LSP being the Devil with an inactive wolf. Most likely all the wolves are active. Meaning the assasination vote was baned or they made the decision not to vote. Was someone baned?

All that is a good point, but forget not that a lack of death doesn't automatically mean somebody didn't send in their votes, but more likely that whoever was targeted was also baned.
True Mr. Carter would make a strange selection for wolf, but that also would be a clever move too. Making the ghost player the dangerous one, sending in his assassination votes at night. There have been a bunch of guest viewers browsing the forums recently, maybe Mr. Carter is browsing anonymously and then secretly assassinating, laughing as people automatically remove him from suspicion solely because he's far away.
The dead have no vote here, so my opinion really doesn't matter all that much.
Also, if TV Face were a good wolf, he would be active in the day cycles too, trying to get some innocents lynched. Just because he only posts at night isn't really a sound indication either.
All i'm trying to say is that the above reasons aren't really reasons much to do anything. But then again i suppose a half-reason is better than random lynching from no reason.

I've seen guest viewers on here too, but not always in europe, a guest browsing from europe may or may not be significant, we could just be getting paranoid. I thought it would get easier as people were narrowed down, but this is tricky. My reasons to lynch T.V.Face have nothing to do with his posting habits, but just that he is a possible wolf that we know is active, and if that's the criterea for my next lynch, then I regress to my previous suspicion, LSP. Even though she looks like a safe villager now and it would actually be suprising if she was a wolf, it was my original opinion.

The suns is going down, night will fall fairly soon...
I think its time the villagers reached a consensus on who to lynch before someone dies who probably shouldn't...

Kuph wrote:

Kuph, you do know the Devil is allowed to vote if they're the only Wolf left, right?

Ah, thank you, I overlooked that. That's important to keep in mind.

You all are missing a huge detail. Nobody died last night. TV fave didn't post at all last night, and isn't it also strange that he only ever posts during the night cycles??? I think at the moment he is our closest bet to lynching a wolf.

also snail knew mccarter was going to be on vacation during this round. Thinking logically, he wouldn't put him in any important role and thus probably made him a normal villager. He's also been inactive for the entire round; i know for a fact the baner put a bane on elmo but we know elmo already died. It would've taken the combined votes of both the beast and the wolf to kill him. Mccarter's inactivity shows that he can't be a wolf.

thus i urge a we all lynch T.V. FACE

Good point, that shatters my prediction of LSP being the Devil with an inactive wolf. Most likely all the wolves are active. Meaning the assasination vote was baned or they made the decision not to vote. Was someone baned?

All that is a good point, but forget not that a lack of death doesn't automatically mean somebody didn't send in their votes, but more likely that whoever was targeted was also baned.
True Mr. Carter would make a strange selection for wolf, but that also would be a clever move too. Making the ghost player the dangerous one, sending in his assassination votes at night. There have been a bunch of guest viewers browsing the forums recently, maybe Mr. Carter is browsing anonymously and then secretly assassinating, laughing as people automatically remove him from suspicion solely because he's far away.
The dead have no vote here, so my opinion really doesn't matter all that much.
Also, if TV Face were a good wolf, he would be active in the day cycles too, trying to get some innocents lynched. Just because he only posts at night isn't really a sound indication either.
All i'm trying to say is that the above reasons aren't really reasons much to do anything. But then again i suppose a half-reason is better than random lynching from no reason.

I've seen guest viewers on here too, but not always in europe, a guest browsing from europe may or may not be significant, we could just be getting paranoid. I thought it would get easier as people were narrowed down, but this is tricky. My reasons to lynch T.V.Face have nothing to do with his posting habits, but just that he is a possible wolf that we know is active, and if that's the criterea for my next lynch, then I regress to my previous suspicion, LSP. Even though she looks like a safe villager now and it would actually be suprising if she was a wolf, it was my original opinion.

You're making a mistake by voting for lsp, and this can be best illustrated for 2 reasons.
1. although you may think she is a wolf, you have little proof. TVFACE is more active, and when looking back to elmos assassination, the reason he was assassinated was because anybody who knows him in real life would automatically take him out of the game since those of us who know him, know his genius. LSP doesn't know him, and the chances of her being in contact with the beast and devil by the first night are highly unlikely, thus the only way elmo would've been assassinated would be if all of the wolves knew him.
2. We already have enough , or close to enough votes to lynch TVFACE. Your one vote against lsp does nothing, why not help your fellow villagers?

i would also like to add that although this all seems a little rash on my part you have to trust that i'm doing this for our good. please don't confuse my honest efforts with 2 faced plots against you.

I understand, right now T.V.Face is is the lead to get lynched and I'm fine with that, but I'm not going to change my vote again.